Upper story of an older stone house with ivory sash windows, a slate gable roof, a dormer and a brick chimney in autumn sunlight.

Class I or Class II? The Historic Label That Decides What You Can Do With an Older Bryn Mawr House

"Are you aware of any historic preservation restriction or ordinance or archeological designation associated with the Property?"

That line appears on the Pennsylvania Association of Realtors Seller's Property Disclosure Statement. On the Lower Merion side of Bryn Mawr, the township's historic resource inventory includes Class I and Class II houses. Lower Merion is also reconsidering the gap between the two.

This post covers Bryn Mawr addresses in Lower Merion Township.

Two Historic Resource Labels

Lower Merion keeps an official Historic Resource Inventory, and its Historical Commission recommends additions to that list and advises on demolition outside the township's local historic districts. Houses on the inventory outside those districts are designated either Class I or Class II.

The demolition process sits in Chapter 62 of the township code. The township's 2026 Historic Preservation Report says the Board's final decisions are binding for Class I resources and not for Class II, and Class I resources have to meet the stricter criteria.

What Two and a Half Decades of Demolitions Show

According to the 2026 report, the inventory counts 177 Class I and 575 Class II resources outside the local historic districts, plus 360 properties inside those districts. Since the inventory was adopted in 2000, 27 Class II and 3 Class I resources have been demolished, and the report says most years saw one demolition or none.

Most Class II houses on the list are still standing. The report explains why. Nearly every Class II review ends with a recommendation to change the project in ways that improve the result, and almost half of those recommendations assign a subcommittee of Commission members to keep working with the applicant. The report also describes the strain in that arrangement when the Commission opposes an application.

Historic Designations in Bryn Mawr

Recent Bryn Mawr cases show how historic designations and demolition proposals have played out.

  • A house on Elliott Avenue. An outside party nominated it, and the owner opposed the nomination. The Historical Commission found it eligible for Class I in 2024, meeting five of the ten designation criteria. The 2026 report says that, with no precedent for designating a home over its owner's objection, the Board of Commissioners voted against advertising a designation ordinance.
  • 600 Black Rock Road. Known as "Swarthmore Lodge" and designed by architect Charles Barton Keen, this house moved from Class II to Class I in 2025 at its owners' request.
  • 901 County Line Road. In October 2026, the Building and Planning Committee voted to advertise a public hearing on adding this log house as a Class I resource, Main Line Media News reported. The owner is the nominator. Speaking to the committee, township historic preservation planner Greg Prichard said the owner "wants to make sure that the house is preserved in its current state and agreed that the Class I designation will be the best way to go about doing that."
  • 850 Mt. Pleasant Road. This Class II house was the subject of a full-demolition application at the Historical Commission's December 15, 2025 meeting. The item was tabled, and the applicant came back with a revised design that reused some of the existing house.

The Class II Rules Are Up for Review

The township's 2026 review could change the distinction between Class I and Class II.

The 2026 report includes an evaluation by the Pennsylvania State Historic Preservation Office, or PA SHPO. It says non-binding Class II decisions do not meet Certified Local Government program standards, and that the lack of binding decisions has led to the loss or major alteration of properties residents believed were protected. PA SHPO staff recommended that the township weigh the pros and cons of the two-class system. If the township keeps classes, the recommendation is to reassess every Class I and Class II resource and make Class II decisions binding. The evaluation also suggests requiring a structural report with demolition applications, covering the building's condition, whether repair is feasible, and how repair costs compare with the building's value. It pairs that with a formal economic hardship procedure, which the township's ordinance currently lacks.

Township staff responded that a hardship clause would be explored, that the code would be amended to clarify the roles of the Historical Architectural Review Board and the Historical Commission, and that the code would describe the subcommittee review process. The Historical Commission's October 26, 2026 agenda listed a staff presentation of two draft ordinances updating Chapters 62, 88, and A180 of the township code. These are drafts in a code-update process, not adopted law.

The Historic Resource Inventory Map

Lower Merion launched a public interactive map of the Historic Resource Inventory in May 2025. It uses separate symbols for Class I, Class II, historic district, demolished, and surveyed but undesignated properties, Main Line Media News reported.

This post is general information about how Lower Merion's historic resource rules work, not legal advice. Before committing to a purchase or a project, confirm how the rules apply to a specific property with a real estate attorney and the township.

If you're weighing an older Bryn Mawr house, Michael Sivel and The Sivel Group can help. Sell smarter. Buy smarter. Move smarter.

Partner With Our Team

We offer the highest level of expertise, service, and integrity. Get in contact with us to get started today!

Follow Us on Instagram